
Original Investigation
JNEPHROL 2000; 13: 275-281
Clinical significance and long-term evolution of minimal change histopathologic variants and of IGM nephropathy among Egyptians
Ahmed F. Donia, Mohamed A. Sobh, Fatma E. Moustafa, Mohamed A. Bakr, Mohamed A. Foda - Urology and Nephrology Center, University of Mansoura - Egypt
ABSTRACT: In children, the most frequent idiopathic nephrotic syndrome is minimal change nephrotic syndrome (MCNS). Typically, MCNS shows no abnormalities by light microscopy: "nil disease". Beside this classic picture, there are other minor light microscopic abnormalities which are considered as MCNS variants. Our 172 MCNS patients were divided into a nil disease group, two groups of MCNS variants (mild mesangial hypercellularity and mild mesangial thickening) and a fourth group with normal light microscopy and diffuse IgM deposition (IgM nephropathy group). The relation of this fourth group to MCNS is controversial in the literature. Age and serum creatinine were significantly different in the four histologic groups (P=0.03 for age and 0.047 for serum creatinine). Comparing the groups in pairs, it appeared that these significant differences were due to significantly higher age and serum creatinine in the mild mesangial hypercellularity group than in the IgM nephropathy group (P = 0.02 for age and 0.01 for serum creatinine). The groups were similar as regards follow-up creatinine clearance and early and late steroid response. We concluded that mild mesangial hypercellularity may differ from other MCNS forms as regards age at presentation and renal function. We also suggest that IgM nephropathy with normal light microscopy is similar to MCNS.
Keywords: Evolution, IgM nephropathy, Minimal change nephrotic sydrome variants
Introduction
Minimal-change nephrotic syndrome (MCNS) is defined
morphologically on the basis of normal glomeruli by light microscopy, absent or
non-specific immunoglobulin deposits by immunofluorescence, and diffuse epithelial cell
foot-process effacement by electron microscopy (1).
Based on electron microscopic and other findings, new data suggest that the podocyte
phenotype may help define MCNS and focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (FSGS) (2).
Additionally, podocyte vacuolization and effacement may have a diagnostic and prognostic
role in MCNS (3). The absence or presence of podocytes in urine may differentiate MCNS
from mesangial proliferation (4). In 1981, an ISKDC report (5) stated that although the
glomeruli in MCNS are customarily normal by light microscopy (nil disease), the
histopathologic concept of minimal changes does, however, include minor abnormalities.
Accordingly, MCNS was divided into five subcategories (variants): (a) Nil disease, (b)
Focal glomerular obsolescence, (c) Mild mesangial thickening, (d) Focal tubular changes,
and (e) Mild mesangial hypercellularity. The ISKDC report described the histopathologic
changes seen in these five subgroups and assessed their clinical significance.
Since this report, no other studies have described MCNS variants according to their light
microscopic features, especially in developing, subtropical and mediterranean countries
where race, socioeconomic status and environmental factors may greatly affect the
patterns.
According to the ISKDC classification for MCNS, we reviewed renal biopsies of our
nephrotic patients diagnosed by a single histopathologist as MCNS. Out of a total of 172
biopsies, 85 were nil disease, 52 were mild mesangial hypercellularity and 23 were mild
mesangial thickening. None of our biopsies was diagnosed as focal glomerular obsolescence
or focal tubular atrophy. So we had only three variants of MCNS. The remaining 12 biopsies
were normal by light microscopy. However, an account of their very specific
immunofluorescent picture, they were diagnosed as IgM nephropathy. It is still
controversial whether this last group constitutes a separate entity or is simply a part of
the spectrum of MCNS-FSGS-mesangial proliferative glomerulonephritis (6).
We conducted this study to correlate three of the histopathologic variants of MCNS, based
on light microscopic findings, and their clinical features among Egyptians. The
histopathologic diagnosis of IgM nephropathy with a normal light microscopic picture was
added to the study and was correlated with its clinical data, trying to clarify its
similarity or dissimilarity from MCNS variants. We also assessed the long-term evolution
of the histopathologic variants of MCNS and of IgM nephropathy as regards steroid response
and renal function.
Materials and methods
Patients
All idiopathic, biopsy-proven MCNS patients were included
in this study. They were collected from a total of 1000 biopsy-proven, glomerulonephritis
patients diagnosed in the Urology and Nephrology Center, University of Mansoura, Egypt,
between 1983 and 1993. Their total number was 172 patients, 108 males and 64 females.
Their age ranged from 2 to 50 years (median 10 years). They were classified into four
subgroups:
1) Nil disease: 85 patients
2) Mild mesangial hypercellularity: 52 patients
3) Mild mesangial thickening: 23 patients
4) IgM nephropathy (no abnormalities by light microscopy): 12 patients.
Clinical methods
We reviewed the history of all patients at the time of
biopsy and yearly for four years thereafter, with special attention to the duration of
disease, number of relapses/year and degree of edema. Any with a history of disease or
drug use that could cause secondary glomerulonephritis were excluded. From examination
data, hypertension and edema were carefully looked for. Investigations to exclude
secondary glomerulonephritis were reviewed. Intestinal bilharziasis, one of the major
causes of secondary glomerulonephritis in our country, was excluded by stool analysis and
rectal mucosal biopsy for those with a history of exposure to the parasite.
Results of urinalyis, 24-hour urinary protein and serum albumin, cholesterol and
creatinine at time of biopsy and at each follow-up were reported.
Histology
One core of the renal tissue was fixed in 10% neutral
buffered formalin and processed as paraffin sections which were stained with hematoxylin
and eosin, periodic acid Schiff, Masson trichrome, silver methenamine and Congo red stains
and then examined by light microscopy.
The second core was immediately deep-frozen (-70 °C). Frozen kidney sections were stained
by fluorescein, labeled antihuman IgG, IgA, IgM, C3, C4, C1q
and fibrinogen at dilutions of 1:8 to 1:10 preparing them for immunofluorescent
examination.
A third core (taken in some patients only) was used for electron microscopic examination.
Clinical definitions
Established definitions are used to define prednisone regimens, steroid responder, infrequent relapser, frequent relapser, steroid-dependent and non-responder (7). Till the age of 17, hypertension was diagnosed if systolic and/or diastolic blood pressure was above the 95th percentile (8). Patients over 17 years were considered hypertensive if blood pressure exceeded 140/90 (9).
Histologic definitions
Nil disease was diagnosed when glomeruli were entirely normal by light microscopy with neither mesangial thickening nor mesangial hypercellularity (5). Mild mesangial thickening was diagnosed when there were slight increases in the amount of PAS-positive mesangial matrix without increased cellularity (5, 10, 11). In mild mesangial hypercellularity there was a slight increase of mesangial cellularity. It was differentiated from nil disease on the one hand and from diffuse mesangial hypercellularity on the other on the basis of the number of cells per peripheral mesangial area. One or two cells per peripheral mesangial area indicated nil disease, whereas three were taken as mild mesangial hypercellularity. Four or more cells were reagarded as diffuse mesangial hypercellulariy (5, 11). The IgM nephropathy subgroup included biopsies with no changes by light microscopy but with diffuse IgM mesangial deposition. IgM nephropathy with light microscopic pictures other than minimal changes was excluded.
Statistical analysis
To test for normal distribution, the frequency of cases was plotted against the normal distribution curve for the group mean and standard deviation. As most of the data showed obvious deviation from the normal distribution, non-parametric statistical methods were used.Non-parametric Kruskal-Wallis analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to compare the four groups. To test for differences between pairs of groups, the Mann-Whitney test was used. Cross-tabulation and the X2 test were used to test for associations between different pathologic types and other categorial variables. The tests were run on an IBM-compatible computer using SPSS/PC+ statistical package (SPSS Inc Chicago, IL). A P value less than 0.05 was considered significant.
Results
The 172 patients included 85 with nil disease, 52 with mild mesangial hypercellularity (Fig. 1), 23 with mild mesangial thickening (Fig. 2)
Fig. 1
Fig. 2
and 12 with IgM nephropathy. The main demographic and clinical characteristics of patients
in the four groups at time of biopsy are shown in Table I.
TABLE I - DEMOGRAPHIC AND CLINICAL CHARACTERISTICSa OF DIFFERENT SUBGROUPSb
| . | Nil | NMH | MMT | IgM | p Value |
| Age (years) | 10 | 14 | 8 | 3.5 | 0.03c |
| Age <6 years | 42/85 (49.1%) | 35/52 (67.2%) | 20/33 (87.9%) | 11/12 (91.7%) | 0.0007d |
| Sex (female) | 34/85 (40%) | 17/52 (32.7%) | 7/23 (30.4%) | 6/12 (50%) | 0.566 |
| Disease duration (months) | 5 | 5 | 4 | 6 | 0.8 |
| Numberof relapses/year | 0 | 0 | 1.2 | 2 | 0.0001e |
| Microscopic hematuria | 17/85 (20%) | 15/52 (28.8%) | 6/23 (26.1%) | 3/12 (25%) | 0.687 |
| Hypertension | 19/85 (22.4%) | 14/52 (26.9%) | 4/23 (17.8%) | 3/12 (25%) | 0.826 |
a. Median is used to describe age, disease duration and number of
relapses/year, and number/total number and percentage to describe the other data.
b. Abbreviations used are Nil, nil disease; MMH, mild mesangial
hypercellularity; MMT, mild mesangial thickening; IgM, lgM nephropathy.
c. Significant (Kruskal-Wallis 1-way ANOVA)
MMH versus IgM: p= 0.02 (using Mann-Whitney U test).
d. Significant (Kruskal Wallis 1-way ANOVA)
Nil versus MMT: p= 0.002
Nil versus IgM: p= 0.014
e. Significant (Kruskal-Wallis 1-way ANOVA)
Nil versus MMT: p= 0.009
Nil versus IgM: p= 0.0466
MMH versus MMT: p= 0.0001
MMH versus lgM: D= 0.0067
Significant differences were observed only for age and number
of relapses/year. The difference in age among the four groups (p=0.03) was due to higher
age in the mild mesangial hypercellularity group than in the IgM nephropathy group
(P=0.02). The number of relapses/year was significantly different among groups (p=0.0001).
This was due to a lower number of relapses/year in the nil disease and mild mesangial
hypercellularity groups than in the mild mesangial thickening (p=0.0009 and 0.04) and IgM
nephropathy groups (p = 0.0001 and 0.006).
Laboratory characteristics of patients in the different groups are shown in Table II.
TABLE II - LABORATORY FINDINGSa IN DIFFERENT SUBGROUPSb
| . | Nil | NMH | MMT | IgM | p Value |
| Serum creatinine (mg/dl) | 0.6 | 0.7 | 0.5 | 0.5 | 0.047c |
| Creatinine cleareanced (ml/min./1.732) | 123.2 | 117.7 | 129.25 | 135.45 | 0.54 |
| Serum albumin (g/dl) | 1.7 | 1.9 | 1.2 | 2 | 0.2 |
| Serum cholesterol (mg/dl) | 359 | 338 | 414 | 360 | 0.31 |
a. Medians are given
b. Abbreviations used are Nil, nil disease; MMH, mild mesangial
hypercellularity; MMT, mild mesangial thickening; IgM, lgM nephropathy.
c. Significant (Kruskal Wallis 1-way ANOVA)
MMH versus IgM: p=0.0112
d. Calculated from serum creatinine using Schwartz's formula for
patients under 21 years and Cockcroft and Gault's formula for patients over 21 years.
Only serum creatinine showed a significant difference among
groups (p=0.04). This was due to a significantly higher value in mild mesangial
hypercellularity than in IgM nephropathy (p = 0.01). However, normalization of serum
creatinine to creatinine clearance/1.73 m2 surface area using Schwartz's
formula for patients under 21 years of age (12) and Cockcroft and Gault's formula for
those over 21 years of age (13) resulted in the disappearance of this difference.
At time of biopsy, there was no significant difference between the groups as regards the
incidence of permanent remission, steroid dependence, steroid resistance, infrequent
relapses or frequent relapses (Tab. III).
TABLE III - STEROID RESPONSESa IN DIFFERENT SUBGROUPSb
| . | Nil | NMH | MMT | IgM | p Value |
| Permanent remission | 26/60 (43.3%) | 13/35 (37.1%) | 4/21 (19%) | 1/7 (14.3%) | . |
| Steroid-dependent | 25/60 (41.7%) | 19/35(54.3%) | 13/21 (61.9%) | 6/7 (85.7%) | 0.3 |
| Steroid-resistant | 8/60 (13.3%) | 3/35 (8.6%) | 1/21 (4.8%) | 0/7 (0%) | . |
| Infrequent relapses | 1/60 (1.7%) | 0/35 (0%) | 1/21(4.8%) | 0/7 (0%) | . |
| Frequent relapses | 0/60 (0%) | 0/35 (0%) | 2/21 (9.5%) | 0/7 (0%) | . |
a. Number/total number and percentages are used to describe data.
b. Abbreviations used are Nil, nil disease; MMH, mild mesangial
hypercellularity; MMT; mild mesangial thickening; IgM, IgM nephropathy. Total number in
each group is reduced because of exclusion of patients who received adjuvant therapy.
Patients who received adjuvant treatment (azathioprine,
cyclosphosphamide or cyclosporine A) were excluded from this analysis. Table IV shows that
this similarity in steroid response continued among subgroups over the four years after
renal biopsy. Patients who did not attend four years of follow-up after biopsy or who
received adjuvant therapy after biopsy were excluded from this analysis.
Serial creatinine clearance done yearly for four years showed insignificant differences
among subgroups.
TABLE IV - STEROID RESPONSESa IN DIFFERENT SUBGROUPSb AT LAST FOLLOW-UPc
| . | Nil | NMH | MMT | IgM | p Value |
| Permanent remission | 3/20 (15%) | 2/10 (20%) | 1/14 (7.1%) | 0/7 (0%) | . |
| Steroid-dependent | 9/20 (45%) | 3/10(30%) | 7/14 (50%) | 6/7 (85.7%) | 0.67 |
| Steroid-resistant | 6/20 (30%) | 4/10 (40%) | 4/14 (28.6%) | 1/7 (14.3%) | . |
| Infrequent relapses | 2/20 (10%) | 0/10 (0%) | 1/14(7.1%) | 0/7 (0%) | . |
| Frequent relapses | 2/20 (0%) | 0/10 (0%) | 1/14 (7.1%) | 0/7 (0%) | . |
a. Number/total number and percentages are used to describe data.
b. Abbreviations used are Nil, nil disease; MMH, mild mesangial
hypercellularity; MMT; mild mesangial thickening; IgM, lgM nephropathy.
c. Total number of patients is far less than the initial population,
because patients who did not continue the follow-up or who received adjuvant therapy were
excluded.
TABLE V -SERIAL CREATININE CLEAREANCEa,b IN DIFFERENT SUBGROUPSc,d
| . | Nil | NMH | MMT | IgM | p Value |
| One year | 123.2 | 117.7 | 129.3 | 135.5 | 0.73 |
| Two years | 116.3 | 134.2 | 126.5 | 121 | 0.42 |
| Three years | 111.8 | 141.6 | 119.6 | 121 | 0.21 |
| Four years | 103.8 | 134.4 | 113.3 | 103.4 | 0.23 |
a. Medians are given
b. Calculated from serum creatinine using Schwartz's formula for
patients under 21 years and Cockcroft and Gault's formula for patients over 21 years.
c. Abbreviations used are Nil, nil disease; MMH, mild mesangial
hypercellularity; MMT, mild mesangial thickening; IgM, lgM nephropathy.
d. Total number of patients (51) is far less than the initial population
(172 patients) because patients who did not continue the follow-up or who received
adjuvant therapy were excluded.
Discussion
The clinical significance of histopathologic variants of
minimal change disease was thoroughly evaluated in the ISKDO report (5). However, similar
studies in developing, subtropical or mediterranean countries are lacking. Our study was
done in Egyptian patients who are good representatives of such countries where race,
socioeconomic status and environmental factors are expected to produce different results
from those seen in western populations. In addition, our study included the subgroup of
IgM nephropathy with normal light microscopic picture. The relation of this group to
minimal change disease is still debitable and needs to be clarified. Some authors consider
that patients with IgM in the mesangium should be considered as a separate entity
"IgM-associated nephropathy" and have a greater tendency to steroid
unresponsiveness and evolution to progressive renal failure (14-16). Others found that
such deposits, as long as the light microscopic and ultrastructural features are
consistent with minimal change disease, did not seem to indicate any tendency to steroid
unresponsiveness or to progressive disease (17-19).
Our study was done in one center and all renal biopsies were examined by one
histopathologist. This was in contrast with the ISKDC report (5) where data were collected
from 24 participating clinics and renal biopsies were examined by four pathologists.
This retrospective study included 172 patients with
idiopathic MCNS, divided into four groups; nil disease, mild mesangial thickening, mild
mesangial hypercellularity and IgM nephropathy (with no abnormalities by light
microscopy). Unlike in the ISKDC report (5) we had no patients with focal glomerular
obsolescence or focal tubular changes.
Sixty-two percent of MCNS patients were aged from 1 to 6 years in our study. This is in
agreement with the fact that the peak incidence of MCNS is between 1 and 6 years (20).
Interestingly, only 49.1% of nil disease group patients were below the age of 6, compared
with 78.5% in the ISKDC report (5). This difference may be due to a difference in sample
size (85 in our study and 219 in the ISKDC report).
his study, like the ISKDC report (5) found a significant difference in age in the
different subgroups. In our study, this difference (p=0.03) was due to significantly
higher age (p=0.02) in mild mesangial hypercellularity than in IgM nephropathy. Again the
number of patients aged less than six years is significantly lower in the nil group than
in the mild mesangial thickening and IgM nephropathy groups (P=0.002 and 0.014). These
findings suggest that IgM nephropathy may present at younger age and this needs to be
further evaluated with bigger studies.
The male-to-female ratio in our study was 1.75 : 1, slightly lower than the ratio reported
by Glassock et al (6) in childhood MCNS (2 to 2.5 : 1). This may be attributed to the
relatively higher age range in our group (2-50 years) than the ISKDC group (12 weeks-16
years), as the male: female ratio comes closer to unity in adult MCNS (6). We found no
significant sex difference in the different subgroups. This coincides with the results of
ISKDC (5).
We did find significant differences in the numbers of relapses/year in different subgroups
(p=0.001). This was significantly higher in IgM nephropathy than in nil disease (p=0.046).
This correlates with the study by Trachtman et al (21) who proved the paucity of nil
disease in children with frequent relapses; among 16 frequent relapser nephrotic syndrome
patients, only four were nil disease but seven were IgM nephropathy.
Our data indicated no significant differences among subgroups regarding the incidence of
microscopic hematuria or bypertension. This agrees with the ISKDC report (5). The order of
frequency in nil disease, mild mesangial thickening and mild mesangial hypercellularity
was similar in our study and the ISKDC report. In both studies, incidence was the highest
in mild mesangial hypercellularity (hematuria occurred in 28.8% in our study and 36% in
the ISKDC report, and hypertension in 26.9% and 20.8% respectively). This supports the
ISKDC suggestion (5) that mild mesangial hypercellularity is different from other MCNS
subgroups. The overall incidence of microscopic hematuria among Egyptian MCNS patients
(23.8%) correlates with that reported by the ISKDC in 1983 (23%). Similarly, the incidence
of hypertension among our patients (23.4%) agrees with the 20% reported by the ISKDC (5).
The significantly higher serum creatinine in mild mesangial hypercellularity than in IgM
nephropathy in our study may again support the ISKDC suggestion (5) that mild mesangial
hypercellularity is different from other MCNS subgroups, or may be due to differences in
age in the two groups, as suggested by the disappearance of this difference after
normalization of serum creatinine to creatinine clearance/surface area.
Serum cholesterol and albumin were insignificantly different among groups, suggesting that
the degree of nephrotic syndrome was similar in all groups.
The pattern of response to steroid therapy was similar among subgroups. The incidence of
permanent remission, steroid dependence, steroid resistance, infrequent relapses and
frequent relapses showed no real difference among subgroups at biopsy. This agrees with
the ISKDC report (5). These observations in our study continued throughout a four-year
follow-up.
Long-term GFR showed insignificant difference among subgroups. This was evidenced by
comparable creatinine clearance values each year for four years of follow-up.
We concluded that, among MCNS variants, mild mesangial hypercellularity has a
significantly higher age at presentation and hence higher serum creatinine. It also has
the highest incidence of hypertension and microscopic hematuria. Although these findings
are likely to affect the outcome of this variant, the three MCNS variants were similar as
regards early and late steroid response and long-term function. We also concluded that the
presence of IgM deposits in MCNS biopsy, the so-called IgM nephropathy, did not seem to
affect steroid response or long-term outcome
Acknowledgements
The authors express their gratitude to Ayman EI-Magawry and Fathya Gado for their technical assistance. The authors thank Hend Sharaby for her secretarial assistance in preparing the manuscript and are grateful to Sahar Abdel-Rahman for statistical assistance.
Reprint requests to: M.A. Sobh, M.D., FACP - Professor and Head of Nephrology Department Urology and Nephrology Center Mansoura University Egypt
References (when available, each reference has been linked to PubMed)
Received: April 20, 1999 Revised: January 27, 2000 Accepted: May 19, 2000
Copyright (c) 2000
Italian Society of Nephrology Back to Home Page